[Milton-L] Re: porno vs. art?

gilliaca at jmu.edu gilliaca at jmu.edu
Wed Nov 30 15:28:54 EST 2005

>Just out of curiousity, is this Moby Dick discussion really 
about a case 
>of censorship, or just parents not wanting elementary, 
middle, or high 
>school aged children reading certain novels? 

In the ALA list, they usually give a very brief account of 
the circumstances - they run the range from parents wishing 
to remove books from school or public libraries, from class 
rooms, from required or optional lists of book to report on - 
you name it.  

I find the removal from libraries the worst, because that is 
not 'protecting' your own child, but removing something from 
everyone. And yes there are bookstores, but one thing about 
the library is it's free and the other is, you can read the 
book IN the library and not risk having it at home. 

It's true that with our technology and our roaring global  
commercial book trade, it would be hard to 'really' ban 
something so that nobody could ever read it. But I find 
fettering the minds of anyone 'for their own  good' 

Such books were not around when I was a teen [a long time 
ago, believe me!], but if I could have read a decent young 
adult novel with a gay character who coped imaginatively and 
successfully with life, my own life would have been quite 
different. Gay themed books that are sympathetic to gay 
characters are often the target of the banners. Perhaps this 
is special pleading.

Cynthia A. Gilliatt
English Department, JMU
JMU Safe Zones participant
"You have made God in your own image when God hates the same people you hate." Fr. John Weston

More information about the Milton-L mailing list