[Milton-L] Struggling with a paper

James Rovira jrovira at drew.edu
Thu Feb 3 18:35:20 EST 2005


I think to answer your questions you'd have to ask either God or the 
Devil directly.  The best I can do is point to a textual tradition that 
Milton may have been following.  Undoubtedly neither God nor Satan are 
nearly as misogynist as Paul.

Jim

BlevinsJake at aol.com wrote:

> Jim,
>  
> Paul of course wrote from the perspective that Satan's deception of 
> Even already occurred, so yes it was woman who was deceived. The 
> question, I guess, would be did it have to be that way? PL depicts an 
> Adam who, I believe, could have been swayed--albeit, as I said before, 
> perhaps by a different mode of attack. The very fact that Adam is 
> not "tricked" by Eve but falls with full knowledge, so to speak, makes 
> it difficult for me to imagine that he couldn't have been tricked into 
> doing the same thing. You're right that an important aspect becomes 
> why did Satan choose to go after Eve first--it could just be Milton's 
> following the "historical" account of the story or the general idea 
> that woman is somehow a lesser version of man, or Satan was privy to 
> Eve's attitudes toward herself at the pool. Regardless, none of that 
> necessitates the idea that Eve was without a doubt more vulnerable to 
> the attack--only that Eve was indeed vulnerable. Remember, Satan HOPES 
> to find Eve alone, but isn't he prepared to tempt the both of them if 
> need be?
>  
> Jacob





More information about the Milton-L mailing list